Gambhir had shown concern about India's batting after 89 all-out in fourth ODI.
Former India cricketer and head coach Ravi Shastri has supported current coach Gautam Gambhir and stated that Gambhir was right in voicing concerns about Indian batters’ poor application in the second and fourth ODIs.
In the second ODI, while chasing the 110-run target in 26 overs via the DLS method, India lost 7 wickets in the process. Then in the fourth ODI, New Zealand had posted 333 runs after being put in to bat first, but India was bundled out for 89 runs, losing the game by a record 244 runs.
Gambhir openly said after the fourth ODI that the team's batting performances throughout the New Zealand tour had been concerning, as they frequently lost wickets in a hurry and were unable to score significant totals.
Even in the recent fifth ODI, India was bundled out for 209 runs, with Axar Patel and Ishan Kishan top-scoring with 46 runs each. However, India's bowlers came to the party, as New Zealand was restricted to 187 runs, and India won the game by 22 runs and pocketed the five-ODI series 3-2.
Despite India's win in the fifth ODI, Shastri stated that Gambhir was right in voicing the issues.
"Gautam Gambhir was right," Shastri said on Sony Sports.
Gambhir expressed fears about the Indian team’s batting, explaining that the environment in New Zealand is similar to the one that they will face in South Africa in the World Cup of 2027.
"You're always concerned when you get bundled out for 90-odd. Why won't I be concerned? These are conditions that are going to be closest to what we might get during the World Cup. It is a bit of a concern, because yes, there is some help here for the bowlers, so we have to be not only mentally but also, from the skill point of view, ready as well.
For me, I think the bigger concern is not the runs; it's how quickly we got bundled out—I think in around 26 or 27 overs. So hopefully we can try to rectify that as soon as possible. There are no unplayable deliveries in international cricket. Matt Henry bowled in good areas, but we should be able to negate that. It isn't just this match. Even in the previous match, we were seven down for 111,” Gambhir had stated in the post-match press conference after the fourth ODI.
Speaking after the fifth ODI, Shastri said Gambhir had rightly noted that these conditions are similar to those India will encounter in South Africa during the World Cup.
Shastri stressed that the batting needed to improve and that the team must realize it does not always have to score more than 300 to win. Shastri suggested that in favorable bowling conditions, a total of 260 or 270 could prove to be a match-winning score.
"He was right in the last press conference, when he said, 'I'm most disappointed because these are the closest conditions we'll get to South Africa.' You expect a better performance in the future, where the application has to be better. At times it will be tough; you'll have to negotiate a period of time. You can't always target 300-320. On some tracks, 260-270 can be a match-winning score," Shastri said on Sony Sports.
India’s next white-ball assignment will be at home, when they face Sri Lanka in a series of three ODIs and three T20Is in December.